Personally, I love a good discussion where you 
can say what you really think and in turn hear 
what others really feel. I liked the fact that 
people seemed to feel free to say something that 
may sound a little negative without worrying too 
much that they were going to get flamed in 
response. It seems like most discussions here are 
either very polite or very rude. The one above 
seemed more natural. I felt like I got to know 
the people here better from that thread more than 
any others I have seen lately. 

I loved to hear about how others felt about 
different shows. It let me see some shows that I 
enjoyed (such as Kenshin-TV and OVA) from a 
different perspective. It was also interesting to 
get a sort of preview on shows I have not seen. 
Nothing that was discussed would cause me to not 
see a particular show, but I will be thinking of 
the other posters here as I watch them. A simple 
list of poor quality shows would have been more 
helpful on what to avoid, but a discussion of 
disliked shows (and why it was disliked) was much 
more interesting. It told me as much about the 
viewers as it did about the animes.