I agree with Fever's Break.  Seemed to me 
everyone was have a good time and no one was 
getting pissy about it... I quite enjoyed 
reading everyone's opinion, even the ones I 
disagree with.  One of the most entertaining 
threads I've read here in awhile.

I don't understand what you 
consider "objective".  Opinions on art, plot, 
music...  are completely subjective.  One person 
can think a show is beautiful and ingenious 
while another thinks its ugly and boring as sin 
and was a waste of time to even make.  Who is 
right?  What are the standards for 
an "objectively good" anime?  If more people 
like it than dislike it, does that mean 
its "good"?  Or..?

:)