Sure buying something simple to resell for profit
isn't illegal, but as for the unethical part,
only if you consider greed unethical. Comeon,
there are shades of grey in the issue -- buying
a set and then selling the cels you weren't
interested is an example -- but we all know when
people are being greedy.
Saying a person with a series of auctions is a
part of retail, is like saying a man running a
garage store is a storekeeper. Stores mark things
up, but they also have expenses -- rent, workers,
utilities, taxes, product (nothing's for free).
With respect to huge bookstores, the net profit
is 3% -- they make money through the volume they
sell. When you start a business or run a
franchise, it takes five years to pay off
franchise fees. Grocery stores have to account
for product that goes unsold and is rotten.
There's a popular bakery near my house which
fills one huge dumpster with stale rolls and
goods each day. Cel dealers fly to Japan and have
website fees they have to pay for. When someone
buys a $200 cel and it goes for $3000 -- the
Ryoko zero cel as an example -- other than
product, shipping, and auction fees, the rest of
the money's pure profit and it's a hell of a lot
more than 3%.
As for saying our complaints are sour grapes is
silly. You've already shown that such behaviour --
call it for what it is SPECULATION -- ruins
markets. As you've said, the card and comic book
market were destroyed because of it. In my
hometown, there were five sport card store. Now
there are none -- not even comic book stores
carry them. The lowest circulation numbers in
comic books was 100 000, now the top selling
comic books are lucky if they reach that number.
As for collectors, people were stuck holding
merchandise that they paid hundreds for, only to
see the bottom fall out and see some of it become
absolutely worthless. The mark-ups in both
markets were ARTIFICAL -- the result of rampant
speculation. People paid more only because they
thought they would get more. Eventually this
stops being true. Now, everytime someone
complains about people taking cels from a
dealer's site or YJ only to resell, I can't help
but wonder how much of the price I pay for cels
is because of them.
(To be cotinued -- whether you like it or
not. :) ) |