I don't agree with Ly's comments completely, but
I do believe noname if you are truly concerned
about the "tone" of the posts and promoting an
overall constructive forum, comments like yours
and Drac's initial one, are not constructive in
attempts to possibly gain greater understanding
during difference in opinions.
I want to speak up for Ly b/c it seems this
disagreement is over her writing style, which
started off as a personal statement and shifts
thereafter. Luna comments, "I think the point is
that I saw Drac's post as a rebuttal: that it
doesn't have to be that way. I think she was
just trying to prove there are ways to enjoy this
hobby without falling into the traps that [Ly’s]
post illustrated." Even though I do agree with
Drac as well, I don’t think Drac necessarily
proved anything, but she did present a dissenting
opinion. Clearly she did not agree with Ly, and
she stated her own positive experiences with the
hobby as her rebuttal. I -completely- agree with
Drac that there are ways to avoid pitfalls
experienced in cel collecting; but like Ly said,
it still doesn't "invalidate" what she wrote. I
think both Ly and Drac presented valid comments
on their experiences on two different sides of
the coin.
Actually, I DO identify with the difficulties Ly
experienced. I will gladly admit that when it
comes to cels, I continue to encounter similar
experiences managing my finances. Once again, so
there are people out there that are better at it,
why is this so offensive? I know I have
difficulties, maybe others such as yourself and
Drac don't, but hey, don't fault us if someone in
a similar situation points this truism out.
Noname you comment, "And the generalizations were
not very complimentary". Does this mean –only-
complimentary posts are permitted now? If so,
rants would cease to be permitted huh?
Generalizations are just that, general, huge
sweeping comments. If it doesn't necessarily hold
true for you, excellent, but odds are there ARE
others who can relate as well. I am not griping
about my problems, but since Ly pointed some that
she experienced, what's wrong? For those of us
including myself who DO have difficulties, should
we also take offense? Personally, I do not take
offense and it's b/c I can relate (even if she
doesn't represent me).
Ly attempts to explain she was expressing her own
thoughts and experiences and that she never said
she was representing anyone else. Cut her some
slack noname and you too Drac, sometimes we all
have difficulty expressing what we need to say
precisely.
Lastly, I initially found this portion quite
amusing, "I found your language and tone
inflammatory... If you really don't know what
could possibly be so offensive about your
statements then you should go take a basic
composition class. You might learn something."
Ah, and you can also learn something as well
noname. Not everyone is going to be mindful of
others opinions, I for one don’t post to win
public support. If I post it will be my
thoughts... take them with a grain if salt or
leave them. If you don't like the "tone" or the
contents of what others including myself say, (no
one is forcing you to respond) feel free not to
write and ignore the post. When I post I rarely
if ever, care if others approve; if they do fine,
but if not, I still won't refrain from stating my
opinions, as I see fit. And that's exactly what –
everyone- is doing on this forum, sharing their
opinions. Moreover, does insulting someone by
criticizing their composition skills actually
make you a better person? Do you feel better now?
|