In the United States, minors cannot legally enter
contracts. They are not considered adults for
purposes of entering any type of legally
enforceable contract.
When you bid and win, you are entering a contract
with the seller to receive a good or service for
which you will pay a certain amount. If a minor
is either the buyer or seller, then by the rules
of jurisdiction, the transaction is immediately
null and void. Thus, if either party is burned,
or eBay is burned in a transaction involving a
minor, they cannot legally enforce (attempt
recoupment of funds, prosecution, etc) the
contract against the minor party. So, if a 17
year old illegally enters a contract on eBay and
flakes out, it's not the 17 year old that is
legally responsible. Their PARENTS would be
responsible for their transactions. So it's not
about "well, I'm a responsible bidder". You may
be, but you're not a "legally responsible"
bidder - which is what is important here.
"Allowing" minors to engage in business contracts
A)is illegal under US Federal Law B)gives eBay or
anyone who does business with them little or no
legal recourse against fraud or theft
This is why eBay will immediately close down
account of minors. To quote the fabulous BIf
Naked, "It's not about me, it's not about you,
it's about life."
Lastly as eBay is an American company, it must
adhere to US laws and jurisdiction. It must also
require it's users to do so. So, to conclude, if
you have a problem, start a grass roots movement
and try to get the law changed. It'll never
happen, but it might make you feel better.
kylaria77
:Business Law was the best class I ever took.
Thank you Dr. Roger Johns! |