I think LP was talking about the important theory
of Blowback -- namely by responding harshly to
terrorist actions, you will be seen as the
problem and not the terrorists. Military action
could easily destabilize an area as anti-American
as the Middle East and spark off more conflict.
As for pacificsm -- what's wrong with it? If
you're horrified by what happened on Sept. 11,
it's hypocritical not to be equally moved by
casualties elsewhere. . . . It's just something
to think about it. The problems in the world are
complex. We need reason instead of passion to
solve them.
Still, I'm of the opinion that if Osama Bin Ladin
truly cared for the people of Afghanistan, he
should have surrendered himself up to the
Americans a long time ago and faced the charges.
The magnitude of the crime was too big for the
Americans to ignore and everyone knew that it
would come to this if he simply wasn't in their
custody. As a friend said -- Americans aren't war-
like, but they're not peaceful either. (America's
military budget is more than the combined budgets
of the next eight largest military budgets. Scary
when you think about it. Thank God America's
never set their mind to world domination.)
"I do not deny that society has the right to
punish a criminal and the right to make the
punishment fit the crime, but to kill a man for
punishment alone is an act of vengence. Nothing
else. Some would prefer to call it retribution,
because that word has a nicer sound. But the
meaning is the same.
"My primary concern here is not compassion for
the murderer. My concern is for the society which
adopts vengence as an acceptable motive for its
collective behaviour. Vengence and violence
damage and destroy those who adopt them, and
lessen respect for the dignity and rights of
others among those who condone them.
"Respect for human life is absolutely vital for
the rights and freedom we all enjoy. Even the
life of the most hardened criminal must be
accorded some degree of respect in a free socity.
If we take that life without proven purpose,
without proven necessity, then we weaken
dangerously one of the fundemental principles
which allows us to live together in peace,
harmony, and mutual respect."
- Trudeau on capital punishment. |