I thought this would be a non-issue, but I just 
noticed a (anonymous) reply telling me that my 
question the other day was off-topic for this 
forum.  Since that thread has scrolled off to the 
second forum page, let me ask it here.

I saw a cel on YJ that was unknown to me.  I asked 
to have it ID'd, and Mia was kind enough to do so. 
 My anonymous commentator said that all YJ 
questions should be posted to the other board.  
Problem is, I don't think this WAS a YJ question.

What's the difference if I see a cel in an Ebay 
auction, a YJ auction, a gallery, or on a magazine 
cover?  If I'm asking for an ID, I don't think 
that has anything to do with the source.  Perhaps 
if I linked directly to the pic of the cel itself, 
this person wouldn't have made any comment at 
all?!

BUT.....I am new here.  And this is a new rule (no 
YJ questions on this forum).  So I'll accept 
whatever the majority (or Yann!) has to say.  
Personally, my interpretation of the rule was: No 
questions about HOW YJ works, HOW to register, the 
outcome of auctions, HOW to get someone to bid for 
you, etc.  Is this incorrect?

JP